Then moving on to the Puritan authors/ministers who, though at least recognized these women to be "fallen" and to be actual human beings, still presented them in this unrealistic light that the women in society in general were one of two things: a.) purely immoral and sinful in all aspects of life or b.) purely good and godly in all aspects of life. It bothers me that the leaders of this society were trying so hard to uphold the word of God by doing right by Him - but in actuality they were probably infuriating Him by not forgiving these women of their sins or at least realizing that not everything, actually not any one thing, is black and white in this world.
Moving on, we've definitely seen the agenda of the author remain stagnant in a lot of these Puritan-influenced texts. In the last few texts we've read, however, I feel that both the author and specified audience is attempting to present the "fallen women" in a little bit more of a humane light and present her situation more fully in the sense that it's finally being acknowledged that there could have been outside factors that have encouraged this bad behavior in these women. Despite this change in writing, the end result of execution remains the same and to me that doesn't suggest that any real change had been realized in society at that time... just that authors probably wanted to be more agreeable to the general public and present the guilty women and their stories as having greater dimension, and possibly with more sympathy. I'm sure these later accounts were more interesting to the public as well and the authors no doubt embellished the truth to sell more copies. I still think these women didn't have much say to what the content of these articles entailed - it may be quite possible they didn't even care, I don't know.
This last account of the Panther Narrative, though, seems entirely different to me. This woman is actually presented in a positive light. She's seemingly abandoned society and its laws by living outside its domain in "Indian country," but she's not condemned for it. She's actually seen as a type of victim who was scorned by her father and lost her lover - but in the end she was saved by these two nice men and received her father's estate and forgiveness in the moments before he died. True, this is evident it's plain fiction and highly unrealistic but I like how for the first time this woman was depicted as a survivor - someone who was dealt a bad hand but got out on top. Though the American people still were no where close to presenting women as equal to their male counterparts, for this time period in writing, I'd say it's a very delightful step up!

3 comments:
Jordan,
I liked your comments about the way the narratives are changing over time. I also want to comment that I really like the layout and design of your blog. It's very pretty! But back to the substance...
I particularly liked your commentary on the hypocrisy of the puritanical culture in judging these women for being "godless." I thought it was an interesting observation. Good post!
Jordan,
You made some really good points about the readings. I agree, I did not really like Cotton Mather's writings either. I also really liked what you had to say about basically the irony in the leaders of the Puritan times. It was indeed very hypocritical the way they would try and uphold the Word of God and yet they would judge people and condemn them without really knowing for sure if they were guilty and then not uphold the teachings they proclaim as truth and not forgive people.
I agree that its definitely a delightful step up! After reading so much Cotton Mather, it's crazy to actually read something in which the woman is seen in such a positive light. Aside from all the lovelier flowery language, the mere fact that she survives speaks volumes. Nice blog, by the way!
Post a Comment