Tuesday, October 21, 2008

oh love...

Honestly, from what I've read in the most recent texts, the idea of "love" and its capabilities has everything to do with the women in these texts, but little with the men. These women seem to start out so pure and naive, and then these men who whisper their little deceptive lies to these women to have sex with them do so with little intentions of actually loving the woman and marrying her but of triumphing over her purity for their own sexual desires. I think at this point in print culture, love is this lofty idea that women and society feel goes hand and hand with marriage, and men (at least in these texts) seem to have no considerations for. If anything, love and the good things that comes with it seem to vanish for these women who feel so ashamed for having physically acted on their feelings of what they once believed to be love. These texts almost make the female reader during this time be fearful of love and wary of the men who may flatter you with talk of the idea. Love, in the reality of these readings, seems to be the opposite of the outcome of the stories of the lovers if anything.
I definitely think a dependence on romantic love could have been seen as a rejection of the patriarchal structure during this time. I'm sure if a woman or man were to really fall for someone in a different social class or of a different race or something to that degree then society as a whole would be displeased and in opposition to the whole thing. I think real romantic love would have been very unlikely to come with an arranged marriage as real love cannot simply be "arranged" and can come from the most unlikely places. I'm sure if any individual were to express real feelings of love for another person outside of their marriage to a planned suitor than it would have been against the social institutions of the time.
I don't think the marriages should have still been arranged even if these women were victimized; I think the women just needed to be a little more independent and have more of a backbone and a good head on their shoulders to be able to distinguish genuine men from the dishonest ones.  In the end, they would have still lived a life of unhappiness had they just had their marriages and lives planned out for them which in my opinion might be just as victimizing as the alternative. 

Monday, October 13, 2008

"Baby you must be tired, because you've been running through my mind all day..."

When I looked up the word "rake," it was defined as a dissolute person, a person often indulging in things such as drinking or sex and lacking restraint. Since high school I've known a lot of men who exhibit these kind of characteristics. Some of them I've even dated, others have just been friends. Over time, however, and most recently since entering college, I've learned how to pick out these type of men from the others. And honestly, they're pretty easy to spot. 
Rakes today come in many forms. Most often these men are usually almost always single as they jump from one lady to the next, from bed to bed, and either just don't want anything more than a sexual relationship with the opposite sex, or can't land a girl who they actually have respect for because those girls are usually too smart to date them.
Secondly, rakes who are in relationships are most often cheaters. These are the ones who you need to watch out for, these rakes are the worst. They start off getting into a relationship intending to be monogamous, but given the slightest opportunity to stray, they willingly do so and attempt to keep their unfaithful ways from their girlfriends but are always eventually caught. 
In my experience, I've dated a rake who was the cheating type and believe me, though I'm a smart girl, this boy had me fooled completely for a while. He would lie and lie and cover his tracks and have his friends lie to me for him; it was really hard for me to actually prove his disloyalty at first. I actually had to call the suspected "other girl" myself and flat out ask her if my suspicions proved true before I could bring myself to dump the guy. Although, this was in high school and thankfully I've fallen for nice guys who are actually honest and haven't been involved with a "rake" in a while.
Since college, however, a whole new group of rakes have shown themselves to me and my friends. These guys are the rakes who reveal themselves most often at night - at parties and at bars. During the day you have classes with these boys, share interesting conversations, and genuinely like them. However come nightfall, the assholes emerge. Get a few shots in these boys and they become a lot more touchy-feely, more outspoken and sometimes just plain lewd. They also become dumber. Their ability to think ceases and you catch them grabbing girls' inappropriately and/or attempting to horribly flirt with anything with boobs. They use corny pick-up lines to "impress" you but unless you're a complete idiot you don't take these comments seriously. For instance, I once had a random guy approach me at a bar and say "Your eyes are so intense, they're just so, so... hollow." Though that's one of the worst lines, I honestly laughed in his face and walked away. He proceeded to continue in his debauchery by calling me a bitch, but hey, if you want to talk to me don't start by attempting to compliment my eyes. You will be rejected. Furthermore, trying to be genuine at a bar after midnight is the best way to prove your ingenuity. 
I will admit, however, that there are some rakes who know how to seduce ladies and are very smart in doing so. These guys are usually very good-looking and suave, they understand how girls' minds work and they know how to make girls vulnerable. They are always very respectful at first, and surprisingly interested in everything about the girl. They want to know their friends, their interests, and make the effort to go on multiple dates with them. These rakes usually don't go for the well-known "easy" girls but instead prey on the unsuspecting virginal girls by getting inside their heads and ideally causing the girl to become emotionally attached to get what he wants from them physically. After some casual dating and his goal of sleeping with her is met, he suddenly becomes "bored" and more distant, soon breaking away from her completely. This rake knows her friends and knows not to show himself around her clique but moves on to a different crowd of girls, different places and different situations. Most often he has been talking to several girls at one time, casually dating each of them, then dropping them and starting the cycle again. 
In a lot of ways, these men are similar to the kinds of men we've been reading about in class. However I do think women are smarter, or at least seem to be smarter and more privy to these men today rather than back then. I also think that during the late-eighteenth century sexual roles of men and women were definitely a lot more strict and enforced upon individuals whereas today society in general is more open-minded in terms of sex and relationships. I think things have changed in the sense that guys can sleep with the best type of woman today and leave her even though they still respect her. I don't think men consider women as "delicate" as they seem to do in the texts we've studied but I also think that men can commit themselves completely to a girl who isn't completely pure as well because sexual purity and virgin status isn't as important as it has been in the past. In current society, personality and compatibility are probably of equal or more importance than virginity but reputation is still very important to both sexes. 
It's easy to go on and on about these types of men, the world is full of them. These boys are usually handsome, smart, witty and the type of guy the good girl believes she can change. Sometimes they do change, and grow out of this lavish phase of their youth. Sometimes they never change. My advice, however, is to befriend them, never sleep with them, and try to positively influence these guys. As a guy's girl who has A LOT of guy friends who act like rakes, I can honestly say that these boys really do want the real thing sometimes, and under all the bullshit  they just need a girl to say no and put them in their place - to not criticize but help them realize the game gets old and the end result is loneliness. Like puppies, these boys need to definitely be loved, but trained. : )

Thursday, October 2, 2008

"The Perfect Woman"

I think these most recent readings about the "virtues" and ideas of what to do and not to do to be a good and proper woman and/or wife have actually been my favorites. Mostly this is the case because it's so entertaining how these male writers perceive or wish women to behave. Some of the ideas are obviously too idealistic and some still hold true today. 
The narrative that had the bulk of ideas/instructions for women that most interested me was the "Address to the Ladies." In it the writer speaks of the "delicacy" of the woman's nature and how important it is to be wary of the seductive man's intentions - as if these women are just highly naive and will jump into bed with the first man that smiles at them. He emphasizes respectful behavior, which, yes is important but really not necessary to spell out for the female sex. I could be wrong, but I'm sure most women knew how the should and should not act. All in all though this article was just so serious it became kind of funny to me. 
I found some ideas comparable to modern day ideas of male/female interactions and relationships, however. For instance, guys today still don't want the ladies to be smarter than them, to be their bosses in business or to be physically stronger than them. Back then and even today it makes sense that men enjoy when women feel inferior to them - I've just never seen it being presented so eloquently on paper as it is in this piece. I also noticed how he specifies that the woman must stay true to her "department," i.e. her place is in the household, not in the office. I guess I just got the impression that a woman's education only extends to what she needs to know to be pleasing to her husband or in a social environment. 
Though it's easy to make fun of a lot of ideas in here, I did consider some to be relevant and thoughtful for today. I especially like the line "Beauty and money without merit will sometimes command eligible connections; but such connections do not answer the wishes of our hearts -- they do not render us happy." To me, that's so insightful because I know there are so many women who are raised to marry a certain kind of man (rich, from the right family) but they don't end up truly happy because though financially secure, they weren't really in love to begin with. I could be reading too much into it, but that's what came to mind after I read it.
In conclusion, each of these narratives offer the same kinds of instruction that you would expect. No novel ideas are introduced here. Men want the women to exhibit "perfection" by remaining a virgin until marriage, doting on them hand and foot and by being altogether pleasing in their presence, "delicate" of mind and body.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Presentations of These Women on Paper

We have read a lot of texts about "fallen" women and I have to say that Cotton Mather's accounts were probably my least favorite. The language confused me and his haughtiness in the way he wrote annoyed me. And the way he portrayed women as not just fallen but witches who are equivalent to demons straight from hell was not only unbelievable but just kind of sad when you consider all the women who were wrongfully condemned and executed for "witchcraft."
Then moving on to the Puritan authors/ministers who, though at least recognized these women to be "fallen" and to be actual human beings, still presented them in this unrealistic light that the women in society in general were one of two things: a.) purely immoral and sinful in all aspects of life or b.) purely good and godly in all aspects of life. It bothers me that the leaders of this society were trying so hard to uphold the word of God by doing right by Him - but in actuality they were probably infuriating Him by not forgiving these women of their sins or at least realizing that not everything, actually not any one thing, is black and white in this world. 
Moving on, we've definitely seen the agenda of the author remain stagnant in a lot of these Puritan-influenced texts. In the last few texts we've read, however, I feel that both the author and specified audience is attempting to present the "fallen women" in a little bit more of a humane light and present her situation more fully in the sense that it's finally being acknowledged that there could have been outside factors that have encouraged this bad behavior in these women. Despite this change in writing, the end result of execution remains the same and to me that doesn't suggest that any real change had been realized in society at that time... just that authors probably wanted to be more agreeable to the general public and present the guilty women and their stories as having greater dimension, and possibly with more sympathy. I'm sure these later accounts were more interesting to the public as well and the authors no doubt embellished the truth to sell more copies. I still think these women didn't have much say to what the content of these articles entailed - it may be quite possible they didn't even care, I don't know.
This last account of the Panther Narrative, though, seems entirely different to me. This woman is actually presented in a positive light. She's seemingly abandoned society and its laws by living outside its domain in "Indian country," but she's not condemned for it. She's actually seen as a type of victim who was scorned by her father and lost her lover - but in the end she was saved by these two nice men and received her father's estate and forgiveness in the moments before he died. True, this is evident it's plain fiction and highly unrealistic but I like how for the first time this woman was depicted as a survivor - someone who was dealt a bad hand but got out on top. Though the American people still were no where close to presenting women as equal to their male counterparts, for this time period in writing, I'd say it's a very delightful step up!

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Women Today vs. Early American Women

  After reading the accounts of these women and seeing how they were perceived by society during this time, all I can say is how relieved I am that things have changed in the sense that society, government, and even religious figures realize that men and women alike aren't perfect, that they are in fact far from it, and this is okay. 
I feel like in some ways, these women are very similar to women in contemporary America as I'm sure they felt fear, lust, love and were definitely prone to temptation sexual or otherwise. I think that probably judging by how strict society was back then, these women had a better sense of right and wrong and probably had better morals than many women of today. 
I think that women today are definitely still judged and stigmatized, though it might not be so harsh and of public knowledge in the way it was in early America. For instance, if a young woman at TCU my age went out 5 nights a week drinking and ended up a different guy's bed each of those nights - she would definitely be thought of as a slut. In this way, a woman today would be "punished" for her behavior by acquiring a bad reputation among the general population of students at school, by receiving the wrong kind of attention from men, and by never being really satisfied with herself in the long run. However, I think this situation would be the extreme for TCU. 
Women today are treated by society, for the most part, far better than women of early America would have  been treated. Society is so much more acceptant of alternative lifestyles that a situation would have to be pretty radical to get much attention from the general public. With shows like "Sex and the City" and "Gossip Girl" conveying the sexual lives of well-rounded, well-respected strong women in a positive light, sex almost seems recreational and the idea of "virgin till marriage" seems to be the more extreme choice. Though there's also "grey" area that could be addressed in all of these ideas, in my opinion I think early America was very traditionalistic, and America today is more individualistic. As far as the specific area of TCU students go, I think most of the girls I know have a great head on their shoulders and follow their hearts when it comes to sex and love. And I think that's the best path to follow. 

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Response to Rountree's "New With of the West"

After reading Rountree's article about this relatively new idea of the modern "witch," I found that I both empathized with as well as opposed some of the beliefs/concepts discussed in the article.
I think for women in general, it's a positive idea to think of the woman in terms of a "goddess" and might do great things for the self-esteem of many women in the world who have been brought up thinking themselves inferior to men. I also think it's a great idea to re-educate people about the origin of witches to convey that the institution of the "witch" has not ever been a real evil but that it is people who have used the term to make it evil. 
I think Rountree's whole "feminist" perspective is a little bit out there, but I think her beliefs come from a good place and that she really does have the interest of the world's women at heart. However, I can't ever see this idea "overlapping" with Christianity, as she mentioned for some women. As a Christian, I too have even questioned the Bible's relevancy at times in reference to women and their current roles in society. Although I sometimes wish verses in the Bible were worded somewhat differently to apply to all women as well as men, I have never questioned God's love for me and would never leave the church so that I could perceive myself as more of a "goddess/witch". 
To wrap up, I felt that Rountree's article and her ideas within in were very repetitive and as a whole I found the entire concept to be radical, even for our time. If some women wish to "self-identify" themselves as witches to make them feel better about themselves, then go for it. But I believe our society will never take this kind of group seriously, and there are many other plausible ways to act as advocates for women in society today and actually create widespread change that aren't so radical and will actually promote the kind of change in perceptions Rountree seems to be craving.

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Wonders of the Invisible World

As I've been reading this very strange book by Cotton Mather, I'm realizing that I don't always understand nor agree with the ideas he expresses in the text. I do, however, agree with him in saying that the idea of witchcraft is not fully understood. Although I'm thinking in different terms than Mather, I feel that I don't understand the "witches" of Mathers' time as much as I don't understand the belief/fascination with them today. 
I admit that while I grew up watching "Sabrina the Teenage Witch" and "Wizard of Oz", I never once considered that these fictional characters were based on actual real-world witches. I think that witches will always remain popular in contemporary media as they are as exciting as they are scary. From Shakespeare's evil witches in Macbeth, to the witch-like characters in Disney's "Wizards of Waverly Place", people love watching these mythical creatures come to life through entertainment. I don't think our society is in the presence of an "inexplicable power," I think our society has and always will continue to create witch-like characters for media purposes. 
Though I realize that Wicca and other neo-pagan religions are very real to some people in our society, I imagine that those people are far and in between and that most people with common sense will know that witches don't exist and that the "witches" of Salem were never witches but simple citizens who were sadly killed for a nonexistent cause. I would think that people who have truly studied these trials in Salem would know better than to repeat history by believing in any type of sorcery today. 
Personally, I have never experimented with witchcraft or had any "encounters" of any kind with the supernatural. As far as spiritual beings go, I believe in God, Satan, angels and demons but nothing more. Considering also witch-like "rhetoric," I can only think of the obvious negative connotations that go with the idea of witches, other than references to specific witches such as "Glinda" the good witch that can also bring about the positive connotations as well. 
Though I can't honestly explain or understand the existence of evil in our world today, I know that evil is not brought about by witches or sorcery, but can exist in the hearts of any person, just as good can as well. I'm sure there are many things in our world that are "evil," and no one person or definition can pinpoint the source. Though in my mind, I believe Satan and his forces aspire to bring about evil in every person, and it's that person's choice whether to act on it or not.